2 min read

Music Industry Unites to Defend D.C.’s RESALE Act Against Ticket Resale Lawsuits

Ten organizations have filed amicus briefs defending the Act against legal challenges from the secondary ticketing industry

On November 13, a coalition of 10 organizations representing hundreds of thousands of musicians, songwriters, performers, artist managers and fans submitted amicus briefs in the US District Court for the District of Columbia defending the District’s RESALE Act.

Quick recap:

  • The D.C. Council unanimously passed the RESALE Act in July this year.

  • The legislation caps ticket resale prices and fees, targets bots and speculative listings, and requires price transparency.

Under attack:

  • The RESALE Act is under threat from two lawsuits.

  • The first, Ticket Policy Forum, Inc. v. District of Columbia, was brought by a group that includes resale exchanges SeatGeek, Vivid Seats, Gametime and TickPick.

  • The second, National Association of Ticketing Professionals v. District of Columbia, was brought by ticket brokers.

The amici:

  • American Federation of Musicians

  • Artist Rights Alliance

  • Fan Alliance

  • Future of Music Coalition

  • Music Artists Coalition

  • Music Managers Forum-US

  • National Independent Talent Organization (NITO)

  • Recording Academy

  • SAG-AFTRA

  • Songwriters of North America

The coalition’s arguments:

  • 1. The resale market serves brokers, not fans, with bulk ticket purchases, bots and speculative listings creating artificial scarcity and driving up prices.

  • 2. The law’s price caps protect fans, artists and workers by removing the profit incentive behind bots and speculation.

  • 3. Uncapped resale does not constrain Ticketmaster. The coalition argues it allows the ticketing giant to extract additional fees and markups from the same fans.

  • 4. Capped resale works at scale. The coalition points to Vermont and Maine, which currently cap resale prices, as well as an example from Western Australia, where one exchange resold more than 4,000 tickets to sold-out Coldplay shows under a cap nearly identical to the District’s.

What’s next:

  • The plaintiffs are bringing commerce clause, due process, and equal protection challenges to the RESALE Act.

  • A hearing on their motions for a preliminary injunction, which seeks to block the law’s implementation and enforcement, is set for Thursday, November 19 at 10am.

What they said:

  • Nathaniel Marro, Executive Director of National Independent Talent Organization: “The RESALE Act is the secondary market’s worst nightmare. It puts the benefits of fair ticketing right in front of the people who write federal legislation. Members of Congress, their staff and federal employees will see firsthand what a ticket market free of price gouging and scalpers looks like. This lawsuit is a last-ditch effort to stop progress for fans and artists across the country and before common sense ticket reforms hit the halls of Congress.”

Related Articles